Quite a few of the best AWD cars of 2020 come from luxury automakers. One is the BMW 2 Series sedan, which is well known for being one of the most affordable luxury models. The other is the Mercedes-Benz E-Class sedan, a car with a punchy powertrain and a dependable reputation.

Some believe that the Benz is always the better buy because it gives drivers a lot of bang for their buck. However, BMW’s low sticker price and fun driving dynamics are still very appealing to consumers. Because both cars have such incredible attributes, CarsGuide calls it a close race between the two.

The BMW 2 Series

The 2 Series sedan is classified as a small car, but the cabin is still surprisingly roomy. All of the interior materials are well-crafted, and you won’t find any ill-fitting elements. The standard infotainment is a little lacking, but the system is still capable of Bluetooth, HD radio, and multiple advanced driver assistance features. The infotainment screen lacks touch capability but is accessible through a rotary knob.

The BMW 2 Series provides plenty of engine and transmission options for drivers. The base offering is a 2.0-liter turbo-four capable of 248 hp and 258 lb-ft of torque. The Gran Coupe models with this engine can have 301 hp. You can spring for high-performance engines, but even the base engine is speedy and powerful.

The Mercedes-Benz E-Class

Even though there are rumors that Mercedes-Benz is slowly phasing out its sedans, the E-class is still going strong. Like the 2 Series sedan, the Mercedes-Benz E-Class model offers a few different engine options. The base engine is slightly more powerful than the BMW’s, rated at 255 hp. Regardless of the engine, every E-Class sedan comes with a nine-speed automatic transmission.

The E-Class is larger than the 2 Series sedan, but taller adults may have problems getting situated in the second row. The E-Class also comes with a few more base features, like automatic climate control, smartphone integration, and a sunroof. However, some critics dislike the fact that you have to use a touchpad controller instead of a touchscreen.

In some respects, the two cars aren’t that different. The BMW 2 Series sedan and Mercedes-Benz E-Class sedan each get their power from a standard turbo-four engine. Both of the base engines also get roughly the same fuel economy. So what is the advantage?

CarsGuide also noted that both sedans only have average warranties. However, the E-Class has the advantage of more standard equipment. The 2 Series sedan also has a cramped second row, although CarsGuide did give it points for its cargo area.

Drive quality

In terms of handling, CarsGuide gave both luxury sedans the same score. The 2 Series can handle corners with ease, and the suspension provides consistent comfort. The steering also feels well-weighted and responsive.

In contrast, CarsGuide felt that the Mercedes-Benz E-Class sedan suffers from mushy steering. Still, it corners well, and there are no complaints about the selectable drive mode system. Power delivery is also smooth and quiet, especially if you get the optional electric motor.

Which sedan is better?

Ultimately, critics feel that the Mercedes-Benz E-Class sedan is a better buy. It may be more expensive, but the extra features and interior space help to justify the price.

However, if you have a small family or are a single rider, the BMW 2 Series sedan could suit your needs. In any case, it’s hard to pass up a brand-new luxury vehicle for under $40,000. The Mercedes-Benz E-Class may be a slightly better sedan, but the BMW 2 Series is still worth buying.