Subcompact luxury SUVs offer style, efficiency, and versatility, combining the elegance of a luxury vehicle while maintaining the compact size. This unique trait makes them ideal for urban driving and easy maneuverability. Luckily, used subcompact luxury SUVs provide an accessible entry point into the luxury market without compromising quality or features. But which ones should you go for? This article will list which vehicles to avoid or pick, considering factors such as performance, reliability, comfort, and overall value according to US News & World Report, Car and Driver, and Consumer Reports. 

Pick: 2021 Honda HR-V 

Honda is well known for its reliable cars, and the 2021 Honda HR-V is no exception. It features Honda’s Magic Seat system, which allows for various seating and cargo configurations, providing unmatched flexibility. It also guarantees a comfortable ride with good fuel efficiency for daily commuting and weekend getaways. Its reputation for reliability and practicality makes it a standout in the subcompact SUV segment.

Avoid: 2019 Infiniti QX30 

Many people agree that the Infiniti QX30 offers a stylish design and a luxurious cabin, but its stiff ride and lackluster fuel efficiency can detract from the overall driving experience. Additionally, the limited rear visibility and inconsistent transmission response pose a challenge for some drivers.

Pick: 2019 Audi Q3

Combining a refined interior with a comfortable ride and advanced technology, the 2019 Audi Q3 offers ample legroom and cargo space, making it a practical choice for families and daily commuting. Audi’s Quattro all-wheel drive system ensures excellent handling and stability in various driving conditions. Moreover, the Q3’s intuitive infotainment system and premium materials make it a standout in its class.

Avoid: 2019 Land Rover Range Rover Evoque

Are you a fan of off-road adventures? The Range Rover Evoque is known for its off-road capabilities and upscale interior, yet its high maintenance costs and below-average reliability can be significant drawbacks. The cramped rear seats and small cargo area further diminish its practicality.

Pick: 2023 Genesis GV60 

The 2023 Genesis GV60 impresses with its bold design and electric powertrain. This subcompact luxury SUV offers a spacious and high-quality interior, loaded with advanced features such as a large infotainment display and comprehensive driver assistance systems. The GV60’s electric range and performance make it an eco-friendly yet powerful option for modern drivers.

Avoid: 2023 Mazda CX-30 

Mazda’s CX-30 delivers a sporty driving experience and a well-appointed interior. Still, its infotainment system can be cumbersome, and the ride quality may be too firm for those seeking comfort. The cargo space is also on the smaller side compared to rivals.

Pick: 2018 BMW X2 

For those who prefer a sporty and stylish package, the 2018 BMW X2 offers agile handling and a distinctive design. Its turbocharged engines provide brisk acceleration, and the M Sport package offers an even more dynamic driving experience. Inside, the X2 features a high-quality cabin with advanced tech options, making it a compelling choice for those seeking both performance and luxury.

Avoid: 2022 Hyundai Kona 

With limited interior space and below-average material quality, many people have mixed feelings about the Kona. It does come with an attractive price point and an extensive list of standard features. Still, it doesn’t fit the definition of a luxury ride, especially for taller individuals, due to the cramped headroom and legroom. The engine performance is also less impressive, especially in the base models.

Pick: 2023 Volkswagen Taos 

The 2023 Volkswagen Taos is a well-rounded subcompact SUV with a spacious interior, smooth ride, and advanced technology. Its turbocharged engine provides a good balance of power and efficiency, while the large cargo area and comfortable seating make it excellent for families. The Taos’ intuitive infotainment system and high-quality materials add to its appeal.

Avoid: 2020 Mercedes-Benz GLA-Class 

Unfortunately, the 2020 Mercedes-Benz GLA’s firm ride and noisy cabin can be off-putting for those seeking a quiet and comfortable drive. This model doesn’t meet the brand’s prestige, featuring limited rear legroom, a small cargo area, low-quality interior materials, and slow acceleration from a stop. 

Pick: 2016 BMW X1 

BMW’s 2016 X1 stands out with its dynamic driving experience and luxurious interior. This model offers ample cargo space, making it a practical choice for daily use and road trips. Its powerful and efficient engines and BMW’s signature handling ensure a thrilling ride. 

Avoid: 2022 Buick Encore GX 

The Buick Encore GX provides a comfortable ride and a decent array of tech features, but its sluggish acceleration and subpar fuel economy can be disappointing. Additionally, the interior materials don’t quite match the luxury standards set by competitors, and some drivers mentioned that the steering wheel was improperly fitted. 

Pick: 2022 Subaru Crosstrek 

Praised for its rugged capabilities, standard all-wheel drive, and impressive ground clearance, the 2022 Subaru Crosstrek combines the versatility of an SUV with the handling of a smaller car. It offers a comfortable, well-designed interior with modern tech features, ideal for city driving and outdoor adventures.

Avoid: 2022 Volkwagen Tiguan

Although this vehicle was made to offer an appealing European driving experience, owners usually reported problems with the cooling component, brakes, and gearbox. There were also issues with the in-car electronics, prompting potential buyers to steer away from the Tiguan despite Volkswagen’s well-known name. 

Pick: 2022 Cadillac XT4

With its sleek design, the 2022 Cadillac XT4 blends style with performance and reliability. Many drivers praise the car for its state-of-the-art safety features, like traction control, lane-keeping assist, and collision warning. Some reported brake noise due to bad pads, but those affected were recalled and replaced.