Skip to main content

15 Red Flags You’ve Bought a Bad Used Car

Many people are drawn to used cars because they offer the opportunity to own a higher-end model at a fraction of the price or to avoid the high depreciation new cars face when they leave the lot. However, the world of used cars can be a minefield, and sometimes, what seems like a great deal …
Muhamed Batu Ak/Pexels

Many people are drawn to used cars because they offer the opportunity to own a higher-end model at a fraction of the price or to avoid the high depreciation new cars face when they leave the lot. However, the world of used cars can be a minefield, and sometimes, what seems like a great deal can turn into a costly mistake.

Inconsistent Mileage Readings

Mike Bird/Pexels

Does the odometer reading seem unusually low for the car’s age? Are there discrepancies between the odometer and service records? If the answer is yes, this could be a sign of odometer fraud. Some unscrupulous sellers tamper with the odometer to make the car appear less used than it actually is, which can lead to misjudging the car’s value and condition.

Difficulty Starting The Engine

Angelica Reyn/Pexels

A car that struggles to start, whether it cranks for a long time or requires multiple attempts to turn over, could have several underlying issues. This could range from a failing battery or starter motor to more serious ignition or fuel delivery problems. Have a professional conduct a diagnostic test to find the cause and assess the repair needed.

Strange Smells

Nappy/Pexels

Unusual odors inside the car or under the hood can be a sign of trouble. A burning smell might indicate an oil leak or overheated components, while a sweet smell could suggest a coolant leak. Musty or moldy odors inside the car can point to water damage or a leaking heater core. Strange smells often indicate that something is wrong and requires attention.

Inconsistent Brake Performance

Luke Miller/Pexels

If the brakes feel spongy or cause the car to pull to one side, it could indicate worn-out brake pads, rotor issues, or even more serious brake system failures. Faulty brakes can cause accidents, especially in emergencies where reliable stopping power is critical. Neglecting brake issues can also result in more expensive repairs down the line.

Unusual Noises

Hassan OUAJBIR/Pexels

One of the clearest signs that you may have bought a bad used car is unusual noises during your test drive. A grinding sound from the brakes, a rattling under the hood, or clunking when you go over bumps indicate underlying mechanical issues. Have the car inspected by a trusted mechanic, as it might require anything from a minor adjustment to major repairs.

Check Engine Light Is On

Andrea Piacquadio/Pexels

A glowing check engine light is a major red flag. Although it could be as simple as a loose gas cap, it might also indicate more severe issues like engine misfires, faulty oxygen sensors, or transmission problems. Ignoring a check engine sign may lead to significant engine damage or emissions issues, which are expensive to repair.

Uneven Tire Wear

Andrea Piacquadio/Pexels

Uneven tire wear can indicate deeper problems with the car’s alignment, suspension, or frame. If the vehicle is properly maintained, tires should wear evenly. However, if the tires are worn more on one side, it could indicate misalignment, bent suspension components, or even frame damage from a previous accident.

Mismatched Or Inconsistent Paint

Călin Răzvan/Pexels

Do you notice mismatched paint or areas where the paint looks different? This could indicate that the car may have been in an accident and poorly repaired. Inconsistent paint can also suggest that car parts have been replaced or touched up due to damage. Structural damage can affect the car’s safety, durability, and resale value.

Rust In Key Areas

Heru Vision/Pexels

Rust is a natural part of a car’s aging process. Still, excessive rust, especially in key areas like the wheel wells, undercarriage, and around the doors, can be a serious problem. Rust weakens the metal, leading to holes and structural damage. Once rust has taken hold, it’s challenging and costly to stop its spread.

Signs Of Water Damage

Tima Miroshnichenko/Pexels

Water damage signs include a musty odor inside the car, damp carpets, water stains on the upholstery, or electrical issues. This damage can lead to extensive and costly repairs. It also creates a hazardous environment for mold, which is harmful to health. Unfortunately, if the car has significant water damage, walking away from the purchase is usually best.

Incomplete Or Suspicious Service History

Antoni Shkraba/Pexels

A car’s service history records maintenance and repairs. If the service history is incomplete, missing, or suspicious, with unusually frequent repairs, it’s a warning sign that the car may not have been well-maintained or could have underlying issues. So, ask them for any available records and verify them if possible.

Slipping Or Hesitating Transmission

Nappy/Pexels

If you notice that the car hesitates or jerks when shifting gears, this could indicate transmission problems. A slipping transmission might also cause the car to struggle when accelerating, feel sluggish, or produce unusual noises. Failing transmission can lead to breakdowns and unsafe driving conditions and is one of the most costly automotive repairs.

Excessive Exhaust Smoke

NordHorizon/Pexels

Excessive smoke coming from the exhaust is a clear indication that something is wrong with the engine. Blue smoke can suggest burning oil; white smoke may indicate a coolant leak, and black smoke could mean the engine is burning too much fuel. Each of these issues points to potential engine damage or failure.

Dashboard Warning Lights

Erik Mclean/Pexels

While the check engine light is a significant concern, other dashboard warning lights can also indicate trouble. Lights for ABS, airbags, oil pressure, or battery could point to issues with vital safety systems or mechanical problems. Driving with unresolved dashboard warnings can compromise the vehicle’s safety and lead to costly repairs. 

Suspension Problems

JDM Kuruma/Pexels

If you notice that the car bounces excessively or leans to one side, these are signs of suspension problems. The suspension system is essential for a smooth and safe ride, as it keeps the tires in contact with the road and absorbs shocks from uneven surfaces. Issues here could indicate worn-out shocks, struts, or even more serious structural problems.